All Articles

Comparing AWS CloudFormation and CDK: Which IaC Tool Should You Choose?

Introduction

Infrastructure as Code (IaC) has become essential for managing and scaling cloud infrastructure efficiently. AWS offers two popular IaC tools: CloudFormation and the Cloud Development Kit (CDK). While both tools help automate infrastructure deployment, they cater to different user needs and preferences. This article explores the differences between CloudFormation and CDK and provides an example to illustrate their usage.

Key Differences Between CloudFormation and CDK

Feature AWS CloudFormation AWS CDK
Language JSON or YAML templates Code in TypeScript, Python, Java, C#, or JavaScript
Abstraction Level Low-level (declarative) High-level (imperative, using constructs)
Reusable Components Limited to macros and nested stacks Uses constructs, making it easier to reuse code
Programming Experience Requires knowledge of JSON/YAML Ideal for developers comfortable with programming
Flexibility Less flexibility for conditional logic Full flexibility with programming constructs
Maturity Mature and widely used Newer but gaining popularity quickly

Example Use Case: Deploying an S3 Bucket with Versioning Enabled

To demonstrate the differences between CloudFormation and CDK, let’s create a simple S3 bucket with versioning enabled using both tools.

Step 1: Using AWS CloudFormation

In CloudFormation, infrastructure is defined using JSON or YAML templates. Here’s how to create an S3 bucket with versioning:

CloudFormation YAML Template:

Resources:
MyS3Bucket:
Type: “AWS::S3::Bucket”
Properties:
BucketName: “my-s3-bucket-example”
VersioningConfiguration:
Status: “Enabled”

Explanation:

  • The Resources section defines all AWS resources.
  • MyS3Bucket specifies the type AWS::S3::Bucket and enables versioning with VersioningConfiguration.

To deploy this template:

  1. Save the file as s3_bucket.yaml.
  2. Use the AWS CLI to create a stack: aws cloudformation create-stack --stack-name my-s3-stack --template-body file://s3_bucket.yaml

Step 2: Using AWS CDK

In AWS CDK, you can use high-level constructs to define infrastructure in code. Below is an example using Python to create an S3 bucket with versioning.

CDK Code (Python):

from aws_cdk import core
from aws_cdk.aws_s3 import Bucket, BucketVersioning

class MyS3Stack(core.Stack):
def init(self, scope: core.Construct, id: str, **kwargs) -> None:
super().init(scope, id, **kwargs)

    my_bucket = Bucket(self, "MyS3Bucket",  
                       bucket_name="my-s3-bucket-example",  
                       versioned=True)

app = core.App()
MyS3Stack(app, “MyS3Stack”)
app.synth()

Explanation:

  • MyS3Stack is a CDK stack that defines an S3 bucket with versioning enabled.
  • The bucket is created using the Bucket construct, setting versioned=True to enable versioning.

To deploy this stack:

  1. Save the file as app.py.
  2. Run cdk deploy to deploy the stack.

Key Benefits of Each Approach

  • CloudFormation:

    • Ideal for infrastructure engineers familiar with YAML or JSON.
    • Works well for highly standardized environments.

  • CDK:

    • More suitable for developers comfortable with coding.
    • Makes it easier to create reusable infrastructure code and apply complex logic.

Conclusion

Both AWS CloudFormation and CDK are powerful tools for managing infrastructure on AWS. CloudFormation is well-suited for low-level control and environments where JSON/YAML templates are preferred. In contrast, CDK provides a developer-friendly experience with high-level constructs and flexibility, making it ideal for complex projects requiring code reusability and advanced logic. Choosing between CloudFormation and CDK depends on your team’s expertise and the complexity of your infrastructure requirements.

Published Nov 1, 2024

Welcome to Vians Tech